I love this podcast. I listen to it after every episode starting from when this podcast began ( it was midway through the series ). I am currently rewatching the entire series. The commentators are smart and have lots of interesting takes on all the themes and the character arcs . I like that there are male and female perspectives also

CONTENT: B+. Fairly smart and insightful commentary and observations, but... DELIVERY: C+. very clunky presentation. Lots of long pauses and awkward transitions and long droning monotone sentences. Long stretches of zzzzzzz. MAD MEN KNOWLEDGE: C+. some of the commentators get some basic mad men trivia wrong and also pass on incorrect information, like saying mimi Rogers was married to George clooney, when it was talia balsam TECHNICAL QUALITY: D-. one of the lowest quality podcasts I've ever listen to. Almost every speaker is recorded at a different audio level, some of them barely audible while others are blaring into the mic. There is a lot of background noise as well as persistent static in many of the podcasts. At least three or four times each podcast I'm tempted to turn it off

Now I remember why I unsubscribed the first time. Long, drawn out discussion on 'maybes' and 'what-ifs.' Their combined basic recollection of past (or just watched) episodes is frustratingly lacking. The female host is constantly laughing at her own presumedly witty comments. None of the hosts challenge each others' opinions.

I listened to a couple of other Mad Men podcasts that were so bad it was embarrassing. This one is really insightful and smart. I am hooked. Thank you for being your pretentious selves!

Apologies in advance for the negative review but these guys are way too serious and seem more interested in prooving how philosophical and intellectual they are. One of the girls especially drones on and on to the point where she gets lost in her own words and ends up contradicting herself. If you want to come away feeling like you just picked up a 20 pound weight full of somber analysis then this is the podcast for you.

This is an informative podcast that takes an in-depth look at Mad Men. My only "complaint" is that it seems they "shut down" once the season has come to a close, which is a shame because I'd love to hear thoughts that aren't necessarily restricted to one episode. I'd love an episode looking at the really minor characters or something like that. Otherwise, great podcast!

The main host has a narrow view of the show.

After scouring iTunes for a Mad Men podcast that didn't leave me arguing with my portable listening devices, I finally (FINALLY!) found this one. What a relief. Thoughtful, intelligent commentary and discussion about each episode and the themes therein. If you want a scene-by-scene recap, there are other places to look. But if you want an academic discussion of the show, you've found it.

If you like your podcast hosts to be as cool and as suave as Don Draper then you've come to the right place. Justin & William host this magnificently well done podcast that insightfully discusses each episode of the AMC series "Mad Men"