binged (ITD) got me into true crime and now MWMH is my fav podcast. live shows are always awesome and i really appreciate how clean the language is bc i can send it to everyone i know and not be worried about an explicit disclaimer lol

I enjoy listening to this duo ! Wish my husband would patiently listen to me tell the crazy stories too. They do have a few kinks namely I will say their ad insertion is really tough they don’t even have a pause we’re in the midst of talking about a death and the next word is an ad it’s jarring.

Listening to this podcast, especially on long bus rides back from football games, is definitely one of the best things I’ve ever done. Keep up the good work!!

I was enjoying the podcast until an offensive comment was made in episode 259 regarding two relatives potentially being involved in an incestuous relationship. Garrett remarked, “We’ve got to be in Alabama or something.” I currently live in Florida but am a former Alabamian. That comment showed his ignorance and willingness to perpetuate a negative stereotype of people who live in the South. I will not support anyone who would readily share negative stereotypes of any group, race, or religion.

I’m not a huge podcast person, but when I tell you, this is the only podcast I listen to that is the gods honest truth. I’ve been listening to them for a few years now and every episode I’m hooked!!❤️🫶

Love this podcast! Garrett’s commentary honestly makes me crack up sometimes especially when it’s a little outlandish and Peyton’s is just like uhm, okay. But, recently the episodes have gotten a little short. Peyton seems really tired. Maybe she is going through something. Make sure you’re prioritizing your mental health girl! 🩵

The podcast is good but please more episodes without Garrett. He’s always confused and asks questions with obvious answers that if he were paying attention he would already know

I absolutely love you guys!! My merch came yesterday and I’m BEYOND HAPPY!!! It’s perfect and it fits perfectly 💕

I am just now listening to the MWMH podcast for a while now. I enjoy listening to it, but can we please stop with far right and far left political nonsense? I have heard it not only on this podcast but a few other podcasts as well that are supposed to be about crime and such. I’m sure we can all agree that crime is wrong and hateful, but it has nothing to do with what side of the fence they are on. I am so tired of politics being everything all the time. If all just turned the “news” off and recentered our life on family, friends and neighbors the world would be a much better place.

I love this podcast and got my husband hooked on it too! Payton handles these stories with such care and compassion and I love her storytelling. I also appreciate Garrett’s reactions. They are such a great couple and I highly recommend their podcasts!

I appreciate your respect for survivors, various religions, P’s sensitivity and G’s hot takes are epic. He always says what I’m thinking.

Been listening since y’all had 700 followers and I can confidently say y’all have only gotten better over the years. I listen every week and look forward to every Monday to start my week off right with y’all!! Have so enjoyed watching y’all grow and can’t wait to see what else is in store for MWMH. If the last few years is any indication, y’all are gonna go far🫶🏼🥹

I LOVE oh no media podcasts. Payton is the best story teller. Garrett is so funny and always says what I’m thinking. Keep it up!

Been listening to this podcast since it started and it’s had its ups and downs but I love how consistent it is and how they truly try to put out content as consistently as possible and really care about their fans. They really seem to know their impact on victims families and their community. I love the banter they have and how they do not have TOO much banter about their personal lives (like 30 min) I like a good 10 min of updates and then into the story, it’s really nice to start out the episodes like that!

I found Murder With My Husband after listening to the collab episode with Heart Starts Pounding. After getting up to date on HSP, I began listening to MWMH from episode 2 all the way to the current episode, and listen every week when a new one comes out. I greatly enjoy this podcast and love Garret’s reactions and 10 seconds! Keep at it! One thing though, I have noticed that Garret seems to be getting darker by the episode with his comments. For example, he said in the most recent episode that if he found out Payton was trying to kill him, he would kill her first… a little morbid. Like I get being into true crime and thinking through scenarios like that, but that might be a bit too far. Another thing, could you add a transition between the story and the ads? And also, BRING DEAR DAISY BACK 🐶 ❤️ I miss it sm 😔 Overall a great podcast though 👍

Screw all the negative comments! If you don’t like true crime or listening to podcasts then WHY ARE YOU HERE?? This podcast is amazing! I am not a usual podcast listener, but as soon as I listened to one episode of MWMH I was hooked! Payton and Garrett, KEEP IT UP! We love you!

I love the way they bring to life cases that we might not have ever known about.

Hi Payton and Garret! My name is Michelle. I wanted to let you both know I listen to Murder with my Husband and Into the Dark and I love love them both. I honestly don’t listen to any other pod cast! You both are awesome! I love Garrets reactions are and how you keep us the listers in suspense! You both do an awesome job I almost listen to every episode and I love them all! I tell all my friends and coworkers about the podcast! Thank you for all of the hard work you both do! Keep up the great work! Love Michelle ☺️

This is my favorite podcast. I’ll only listen to MWMH and Into the Dark

I love this show so much! I just found it a few weeks ago and am already on episode 143 🤣. Strongly recommend!

Payton is a very good storyteller and I enjoy listening to her. I’m not a fan of the husband’s random points and commentary.

I just wanna say Payton I wish we could be friends!! But I live too far, unfortunately. When you cry, I’m already emotional and I say that’s my girl, she gets it lol. I listened to the last episode about Blaze, I said I have to leave a review and I cried like a baby with you at the end. That was a hard episode to get through. I’ve been a listener since day one and I also listen to into the dark faithfully. I love your journey with mental health, and the encouraging words. It just always seems to be the right timing. You and Garrett are the best! I do want to suggest that you read some reviews on the show if you have time, I know that you read them but it’d be nice to know that you see us cause we love you! I’m so proud of how far y’all have come. Thank you for being you Payton.

It a fun thing to listen to when I’m doing things around the house or just chilling.

First of all, I LOVE you guys and all your podcasts. My family and I recently drove to FL from NJ and back. 15 hours plus! My husband and I listened to your podcast the whole way down and back and we both agree- it kept us sane and helped the time go by so much quicker! Thank you guys!

Hi MWMH PODCAST, I just wanted to say thank you for putting out great content I love the show. I love the emotion in both Garrett and you Payton. Great podcast, keep up the great work. Appreciate you both!!

I was appalled that 10/mo (which is a really high subscription cost!) doesn’t actually get you ad free episodes. In addition, this podcast has the most obnoxious ads out of any podcast that I listen to. All of the sudden, without warning, Peyton is screeching at the top of her lungs about better help or some meal service. It’s so unnecessary and I’ll never buy anything they advertise either.

Love this show got hocked and listens to every episode in like two days

Garrett is needed to level out Paytons whiney voice.. probably would never listen to each one individually.

I have caught up on every single episode and rewatched some on YouTube on my own time. My clients and I absolutely love this podcast and ride for the victims so hard. We have out own little convos based off the episodes and it’s just so nice.

My fiancé & I were recently on a road trip and spent roughly 25-30hrs stuck in the car together so we ended up burning out on music and she had the idea to try a podcast.. neither of us listen to podcasts but this was the first one we tried… we ended up spending the rest of our trip listening to randomly selected episodes. That Monday while at work I continued doing listening to randomly selected episodes and then about half way through the day I decided to start at the beginning (episode 2) and listen in order.. now it’s Wednesday and I’m now through episode 20.. I never even cared for true crime or podcasts before but I just can’t get enough!!! I will say my one complaint is that I am subscribed for the $9.99 a month subscription but on the early episodes I still get the adds

I love this podcast and I listen every single week. I found your tik tok and I was hooked instantly, and I had to subscribe and listen to all the back episodes. I also love and religiously listen to into the dark as well. That being said, i have a small favor. I NEEEEEED for you to check the pronunciation of any words that you’re unsure of, you’re BUTCHERING words almost every single episode and makes you appear less intelligent than o think you are. I feel like your episodes are so well researched and informative that you’re doing yourself a disservice not knowing the proper pronunciation.

I love your podcast listening to it every week and can’t wait for new episodes !!! I would love to listen to binge but I can’t find it would you have a link for me thank you so much

I’ve listened to every single episode including bonus episodes and I just love love love. If I could give a critiques it would be posting a new episode everyday🤣🫶🏼

I enjoy the show but always wish G would jus shhhh…for a minute and let us hear how this plays out. Sometimes I think he misses the point of what’s happening or going to happen bc he isn’t familiar with TC.

Good topics but Garrett especially is really insensitive about DV, abuse, and at times is victim blaming for jokes. It’s grating to listen to him wonder about things for another week rather than look into what the law says. Seriously, bring a lawyer on to the podcast so Garrett can get all his questions answered. And please take some sensitivity training or something, I’m tired of Garrett’s hot takes about things he doesn’t understand, treating cases like they are black and white and everyone should get the death penalty. Ahhhhhh

I loved MWMH and used to subscribe to OH NO MEDIA until…..his response in the most recent episode to the psychiatrist and her cousin being in bed together made me roll my eyes all the way to the unsubscribe button. Minus one Alabama native listener. 🤷‍♀️

Good show, I’ve enjoyed all episodes. I do have a suggestion, maybe if you can do a MMIWP missing & murdered indigenous “season” or choose more stories. There are hundreds of stories to choose from. It can also raise awareness and help with the cause.

It is really hard to even get to the meat because it’s long introS. Borrring.

The ads just keep getting longer and longer. It’s cool to have ads but its getting to the point where the ads are over 3 minutes long and more frequent.

I like the hosts, I like the topics, I like the banter… but research and care needs be taken seriously. Topics require looking into, ideas fully formed and understanding of things like psychology are important for true crime podcasts. There are a lot of words pronounced incorrectly and ideas that aren’t understood that seem like really simple fixes if time was taken.

If “I actually do cuss a little 😏” was a podcast.

I look forward to new episodes each week and really enjoy Payton and Garret’s personalities!

Best part of my Monday! Love you guys so much! Will be a forever fan 🤍 Payton you are so talented and garret you provide amazing comedic relief; thank you guys so much!

I am a full time single mom... 24/7 365. Although I'm so grateful for my human sometimes I need mommy time and this includes some kind of work out going for a walk and of course anything true crime.. I heard about your show from another podcast HEARTS START POUNDING... I wrote y'alls podcast name down because I was in the middle of bingeing that podcast but now that I've completed THAT I've been listening to to y'alls podcast for a month straight. You guys are amazing together and compliment each other every well especially when the skins commercial comes on! You're an amazing story teller PLEASE keep them coming because y'alls podcast is this mama's peace! Love y'all!

I’ve listened to almost every episode, including subscriber episodes. Would really appreciate it if there was a music break or something for the ads. It is really annoying when I’m deep into the story and an ad pops up. Also, the way the ads are done are really annoying. Don’t need to yell in my ear about rocket money. It is infuriating - I just couldn’t even finish the latest episode because of that. Plus ~5-10 minutes of ads in a 45 minute episode where you spend the first five minutes talking isn’t giving us decent length episodes. Also, wikipedia isn’t a reliable source. News articles, books, or peer reviewed journals should be used.

Nothing takes you out of the moment or seems to be a smidge disrespectful to the person you are talking about… than to have a sentence that goes something like “and then they found her body ROCKET MONEY… la la la Ad!” I get what the point is, but man, it’s like a brick to the face. It sounds like someone flopped ads in wherever it looked good time-wise. Seems like it would be more respectful to announce the ad rather than to be discussing someone’s murder in a run-on ad for Rocket Money.

I love true crime and hearing the stories. I’ve listened to different podcasts over the years but this one is so good! Reliable, straight to the point, detailed, engaging, and just great. I don’t like when crime podcasts have a second person because too many side convos have but having her husband on the podcast was literally not an issue! He doesn’t interrupt or get off topic, he asks clarifying questions, makes good comments. I literally never leave reviews but this podcast is now my favorite! Within the last 2 days I’ve listened to 15 episodes already. 10/10 can’t even complain about anything! Please don’t ever stop this podcast.

Payton fine she sexy she cool she talented Best podcast ever can't imagine the work she puts into it and she talks about the victim more which I love and shows awareness towards their life and story more

The first thing I listen to every Monday! Love the podcast and all of the Oh No Media shows!!

Ahhh, I started listening to your guys podcast in i think the end of November/ beginning on December and I am officially caught up!!! I love love love it so much, I’ve gotten other people to listen now!! I’m heading over to Peyton’s podcast now to start there!!! I feel like we’re friends and I know you guys lol. Even on the episodes Garret isn’t on somehow I seem to know what he’s going to say in certain parts of the show lol. Keep it up!!! I can’t watch to catch a twitch stream too!!! Can’t wait for next weeks episode ☺️